The Confidence Myth: Why Being Wrong Can Be Your Superpower

Discover how real confidence is built not on perfection, but on the courage to show up, speak up, and screw up—without fear.

Friday, March 28, 2025

Confidence comes not from always being right but from not fearing to be wrong.

— Peter T. McIntyre

Meaning and Expanded Interpretation:

At its core, this quote shifts the traditional understanding of confidence. Many people believe that confidence is built by always having the right answers, never failing, and consistently proving oneself. But Peter T. McIntyre challenges that notion.

True confidence, he says, doesn’t come from perfection. It comes from courage. From the willingness to act even when you're uncertain. From being okay with getting it wrong—because getting it wrong doesn’t mean you are wrong; it means you're learning.

Confidence grows when you stop tying your self-worth to being right and instead lean into curiosity, experimentation, and growth. It’s about releasing the fear of failure and embracing mistakes as part of the process. When you do that, you liberate yourself from the need to be perfect and open yourself to progress, improvement, and ultimately, success.

🔍 Breaking it Down for Self-Improvement:

  • Perfection is not the goal—progress is.

  • Mistakes are not the enemy—they are the teachers.

  • The real fear to overcome is not failure, but the fear of trying.

Confidence built on perfection is fragile—it breaks the moment you're wrong. But confidence built on courage is resilient—it grows each time you rise after a fall.

🌱 Personal Growth Application:

  • Ask more questions, even if they make you feel vulnerable.

  • Speak up in meetings even when you’re not 100% sure.

  • Try something new without worrying about looking foolish.

  • Accept that getting it wrong is part of getting it right—eventually.

When you stop fearing being wrong, you start showing up more fully, and that presence, that willingness, is where real confidence lives.

🧠 Context & Origin:

Peter T. McIntyre (1910–1995) was a New Zealand painter and war artist, known for documenting World War II through his art. Though primarily known for his visual work, he was also a writer and thinker. This quote likely comes from his reflections on creativity, risk-taking, and the courage required not just on the battlefield or in art—but in everyday life.

Creative professionals often deal with self-doubt and fear of criticism. McIntyre's insight encourages people to move past the paralysis of perfectionism and find strength in vulnerability and perseverance.

💬 Final Thought:

Confidence isn’t about having all the answers—it's about having the courage to show up, even with questions.

This mindset doesn’t just build better leaders, creators, and doers—it builds stronger, more resilient humans.

📚 Resource List: Building Confidence Through Courage, Not Perfection

  1. Book – "The Gifts of Imperfection" by Brené Brown
    A powerful guide on letting go of who we think we’re supposed to be and embracing who we are—with courage, compassion, and connection.

  2. TED Talk – "The Power of Vulnerability" by Brené Brown
    Watch on TED.com
    Explores how vulnerability is not a weakness but the birthplace of confidence, creativity, and authenticity.

  3. Book – "Mindset: The New Psychology of Success" by Carol S. Dweck
    Explains the difference between a fixed mindset and a growth mindset—and how embracing mistakes leads to true confidence and learning.

  4. Podcast – The Tim Ferriss Show, Episode with Elizabeth Gilbert
    A candid discussion about fear, creativity, and taking action despite not feeling “ready” or “right.”

Quote Collection – "Daily Stoic" by Ryan Holiday
Offers daily meditations from Stoic philosophers like Marcus Aurelius and Seneca, reinforcing the idea of resilience, humility, and inner strength.